Analysis: Poverty on upswing
Poverty in Wisconsin hit its highest level in 30 years during a five-year period that ended in 2014, according to a new analysis by the University of Wisconsin-Madison's Applied Population Laboratory.
'The data tell us that poverty has been getting worse in Wisconsin,' says Malia Jones, an assistant scientist and social epidemiologist at the lab. 'Poverty went up significantly, even during a time when the nation's economy was improving.'
The analysis compared U.S. Census Bureau data from 2005-09 to numbers from 2010-14 and found that the number of state residents living in poverty hit 13 percent during the five years ending in 2014 — the highest rate since 1984.
During the most recent five-year span, poverty increased significantly in 31 of 72 Wisconsin counties, including 11 of the 15 most populous counties. Estimates show that about 738,000 Wisconsin residents were living in poverty, compared to 605,000 in the previous five-year period.
The uptick was also reflected in the number of Wisconsin children touched by poverty. The analysis showed 18.5 percent of children in Wisconsin, or about 239,000 statewide, were living in poverty - up from 14.6 percent in 2005-09. Only 10 states had faster rates of increase in child poverty than Wisconsin, according to the lab's analysis.
'Children's exposure to poverty is a real health concern,' says Jones. 'That's the group that epidemiologists worry about most. There is some good evidence that living in poverty and experiencing issues like food and housing insecurity can cause changes in the brain that can lead to behavioral issues and low performance in school, as well as chronic disease later in life.'
Poverty in rural America
Jones said analysis also illustrated an an increase in poverty in rural as well as urban areas. Poverty in rural Wisconsin went from 7.5 percent in 2005-09 to 9.1 percent in 2010-14.
'Looking at the 34 primarily rural counties in Wisconsin only, among those we see a statistically significant increase in total poverty in 14 of them, and an increase in child poverty in 11 counties,' Jones said. 'The rural child poverty rate was 17.3 percent in 2005-09 and went up to 20.8 percent in 2010-14. This is higher than the state average and just barely below the national average for child poverty.'
Even though the poverty rates in rural areas are overall lower than in urban areas, poverty is highly concentrated in certain rural parts of the state.
'Menominee county has by far the highest poverty rate in the state for both adults, 29.3 percent, and children, 44.8 percent — a number I find truly staggering,' Jones said. 'However, it's not just Menominee county. Nine of 10 highest counties for child poverty are rural — the 10th is Milwaukee.
The top nine rural counties are ranked by their child poverty rate:
· Clark — 23.9%
· Vernon — 24.9%
· Monroe — 24.9%
· Burnett — 25.2%
· Ashland — 25.3%
· Rusk 28.9%
· Jackson — 30.1%
· Sawyer — 33%
· Menominee — 44.8%
'However, the good news for these concentrated poverty rural counties is that most of them did not increase in poverty/child poverty over these two periods,' Jones said. 'Only Clark and Jackson county had significant increases in child poverty. Monroe had a significant increase in total poverty, but not child poverty.'
The analysis also found other unsettling trends in poverty across Wisconsin.
Racial divides were clearly evident in the data, as Wisconsin's poverty rate for blacks was 39 percent and 28 percent for Latinos, compared to 11 percent for whites — significantly wider than the gaps for the rest of the country. Nationally, the analysis reported that the gap between blacks and whites was 16 percentage points and for Latinos and whites it was 13 percentage points.
'It is getting worse despite some recent efforts to address disparities,' says Jones, who adds that she hopes the lab's findings help inform policymaking decisions at all levels.
Poverty rates were also up across every level of educational achievement during the five-year period. For those with less than a high school education, poverty rose from 20.5 percent to 24.5 percent, but the impact was mitigated by a decrease in the total population with very low educational attatinment, which dropped from 380,000 to 337,000.
Impact of education
For those with a high school education, poverty rose from 8.9 percent to 11 percent. It also rose from 6.6 percent to 8.9 percent among those who had attended some college, and poverty also touched those with bachelor's degrees or more, rising from 3 percent to 3.6 percent.
'We think of college-educated people as those who can most readily benefit from an improving economy, so that surprised me,' Jones says.
The analysis also found that poverty cut across various levels of employment in Wisconsin. Among those who were unemployed, poverty increased from 27 percent to 31.6 percent. But increases were also seen among the working poor. The data show that poverty among employed adults rose from 6 percent to 7 percent and increased among those employed fulltime from 2 percent to 2.4 percent.
The Applied Population Lab is housed in the university's Department of Community and Environmental Sociology in the College of Agricultural and Life Sciences. Several staff and faculty in the lab have UW-Extension appointments and play a key role in carrying forward a program of demography for UW-Extension.
The lab's report on Wisconsin poverty can be found online at http://go.wisc.edu/apl_wi_poverty_report.